護教學是甚麼﹖一般福音派對護教學的定義
WHAT IS APOLOGETICS?
A General Evangelical Definition
1. 「護教學」的字意 The Meaning of the Word “Apologetics”
a.
字根﹕apologia, apologesthai, 在新約《聖經》出現八次──
回答（彼前三﹕15），
分訴（徒廿二﹕１、廿五﹕16，林前九﹕3），
申訴（提後四﹕16），
辨明（腓一﹕７，16）。
Etymology (the root of the word): apologia, apologesthai –
appeared in the New Testament 8 times.
To reply (I Peter
To argue/defend: Acts
22:1, 25:16, I Cor. 9:3).
To appeal: II Tim.
4:16.
Phil. 1:7, 16.
b.
基督教護教學﹕福音派一般定義﹕以《聖經》神學的事實證實基督教的真理，面對哲學、科學上的問題，為正統信仰作出辯護。
不過，護教學也有它正面宣講福音的一面。
A general evangelical definition of apologetics: to “prove” the truth(s)
of Christianity, in light of questions in philosophy and science.
A defense of the orthodox (Bible-believing) Christian faith.
However there is also a positive side to apologetics: apologetics is a
form of declaration of the gospel.
c.
深層分析﹕基本的三個層面﹕
In depth analysis: three basic dimensions of apologetics:
i. 辯護﹕為基督教信仰辯護，提出合理的基礎。
Defense: a defense
of the Christian faith, to provide a reasonable for believing in the Christian
gospel (religion).
ii. 論據﹕提出證據、論證。
Evidences: to
provide “proofs,” “evidences” for the Christian faith.
iii.
反攻及攻擊﹕揭露對方的預設（揭底牌）。
Counter-offense: to
expose the presuppositions of the non-Christian position.
Practical Uses of
Apologetics – A General Evangelical Understanding
a. 透過解答人所問的問題，消除人對福音的誤解。
As we answer
questions, apologetics removes misunderstanding of the gospel.
b. 糾正人對福音的態度，以致不再認為信耶穌是迷信、盲目，基督教是西方文化的產品等。
Apologetics can
correct people’s misplaced attitudes toward the gospel; so that they no longer
regard belief in Christ as “superstition”, or think that Christianity is a
product of western culture, etc.
c. 在護教的談話中，從問題帶出福音，為傳福音鋪路。其實，預設派認為﹕護教是佈道的一種。
Through an
apologetic dialogue, we can bring forth the gospel. Apologetics is a prelude to direct
(proclamatory) evangelism. (Actually, presuppositioalists
believe that biblical apologetics is a form of evangelism/preaching.)
d. 提供信心在理性方面的基礎，因信心也建基於預設和事實。
(注﹕理性是墮落的，因此「理性的基礎」是以《聖經》為基礎與標準。)
Apologetics can
provide a “reasonable” foundation for our faith. The Christian’s faith is built on
presuppositions and facts which come from God’s revelation in Scripture. (Man’s reason is fallen, therefore a
“reasonable foundation” is built on Scripture.
Scripture is the foundation and the norm for our faith.)
Basic types of apologetics.
福音派護教方法或體系分為﹕前設的（預設派）及證據的方法（證據派）。
Generally, there are two
evangelical approaches to apologetics, or two schools:
Presuppositionalism and
Evidentialism.
a. 預設派 Presuppositionalism
b.
證據派 Evidentialism
c.
古典派 Classical
apologetics
預設派護教學 ﹕主要觀念
PRESUPPOSITIONALIST APOLOGETICS:
MAJOR CONCEPTS
大師﹕范泰爾 (1895-1987) ﹔薛華; John Frame;
Greg Bahnsen等。
Master apologist: Cornelius Van Til
(1895-1987); also: Herman Douyeweerd (Calvinistic philosophy/Amsterdam School;
Popularizer: Francis Schaeffer, William Edgar
(www.wts.edu). Interpreters: John Frame
(www.rts.edu), Greg Bahnsen (www.reformed.org), Scott Oliphint
(www.wts.edu).
(Note: Not all popularizers of Van Til’s
thought are approved by Van Til as a true interpreter of his ideas.)
一些基礎性的經文 SOME
FOUNDATIONAL TEXTS
彼前I Peter 3:15
只要心裏尊主基督為聖。有人問你們心中盼望的緣由，就要常作準備以溫柔敬畏的心回答各人。
- 尊基督為主（聖）。Honor Christ as Lord
- 要說出心中盼望的緣由。Give an answer for hope in you
- 以溫柔，敬畏的態度。With reverence and gentleness
林後II Corinthians 10:4-5
4 我們爭戰的兵器，本不是屬血氣的，乃是在上帝面前有能力，可攻破堅固的營
壘，
5 將各樣的計謀，各樣攔阻人認識上帝的那些自高之事，一概攻破了，又將所有
的心意奪回，使他都順服基督。
- 我們的武器﹕屬靈，不屬血氣。Our weapons
are spiritual, not fleshly
- 對象﹕人心意（思想）中自高、抵擋上帝、攔阻人認識上帝的意念（營壘）。
Our
target are the proud thoughts against God
- 爭戰的目的﹕將人的心思奪回。
Our
warfare is to capture minds
- 奪回的心思﹕信靠，順服基督。
Our
goal is the faith and obedience of minds to Christ.
- 范泰爾的護教學強調揭露出《聖經》的世界觀，和非基督徒的世界觀如何截然不同。
Van Til’s
apologetic strategy of antithesis: showing/exposing the radical difference between
the Christian and the non-Christian’s worldview.
箴Proverbs
26:4 - 5
4 不要照愚昧人的愚妄話回答他，恐怕你與他一樣。
5 要照愚昧人的愚妄話回答他，免得他自以為有智慧。
- #1: 不要照愚昧人的愚妄話回答他（不要跟他的思想模式、世界觀、預設回答）。Do not answer a fool according to his folly
(according to his line of thought).
- 原因﹕恐怕你會像他一樣（跟他的思路、預設）﹕走冤枉路，走錯方向。
Reason: You would be just like him (in his line
of thought, presuppositions).
- #2: 要照愚昧人的愚妄回答他（跟著他的思路走）。
Do answer a fool according to his folly (follow
his line of thought).
- 原因﹕揭露他的愚妄﹕即他思想背後的世界觀、預設、底牌、心中的堅持。
Reason: To expose his folly – worldview, presuppositions,
bottom line, commitments.
羅Romans 1:18-23
18 原來上帝的忿怒，從天上顯明在一切不虔不義的人身上，就是那些行不義阻擋真理的人。
19 上帝的事情，人所能知道的，原顯明在人心裏。因為上帝已經給他們顯明。
20 自從造天地以來，上帝的永能和神性是明明可知的，雖是眼不能見，但藉著所造之物，就可以曉得，叫人無可推諉。
21 因為他們雖然知道上帝，卻不當作神榮耀祂，也不感謝祂，他們的思念變為虛妄，無知的心就昏暗了。
22 自稱為聰明，反成了愚拙，
23 將不能朽壞之上帝的榮耀變為偶像，彷彿必朽壞的人，和飛禽走獸昆蟲的樣
式。
- 人人都認識上帝ALL men/women know God.
- 因上帝在人心中啟示Because God has revealed himself IN all
men/women.
- 因上帝在受造物中啟示And God has revealed himself through all his
creation.
- 可是人的不義在於阻擋，壓抑這知識But ALL suppress this knowledge.
- 因此人人都不認識（敬拜）上帝；不是因為不知道，乃是因為雖然明明知道，卻壓抑所知道的。Thus all men/women do NOT know God. Not because they do not know, but even though
they know, they suppress what they know.
- 不認識上帝（壓抑啟示）之同時，人類敬拜偶像（受造之物，包括自己）。At
the same time that they
do not know (worship) God, they worship idols (created things, including
themselves).
- 這裏 「知道」有兩個意義﹕第一，上帝的普遍啟示是清晰的，因此人人知道上帝。Two meanings of “know.” #1: Clarity of general revelation: ALL know
God.
- 第二，人人因為阻擋真理，因此不按照上帝的約來順服、敬拜、信靠祂。第二種的知道是守約信服 (covenant faith and obedience). #2: All suppressed this knowledge, so ALL do
not give God “covenant faith and obedience”
徒Acts 17:16-31
16 保羅在雅典等候他們的時後，看見滿城都是偶像，就心裏著急。
17 於是在會堂裏，與猶太人，和虔敬的人，並每日在市上所遇見的人辯論。
18 還有以彼古羅和斯多亞兩門的學士，與他爭論。有的說，這胡言亂語的要甚
麼。有的說，他似乎是傳說外邦鬼神的。這話是保羅傳講耶穌，與復活的道。
19 他們就把他帶到亞略巴古說，你所講的這新道，我們也可以知道麼。
20 因為你有些奇怪的事，傳到我們耳中。我們願意知道這些事是甚麼意思。
21 雅典人，和住在那裏的客人，都不顧別的事，只將新聞說說聽聽。
22 保羅站在亞略巴古當中，說，眾位雅典人哪，我看你們凡事很敬畏鬼神。
23 我遊行的時候，觀看你們所敬拜的，遇見一座壇，上面寫著未識之神。你們所不認識而敬拜的，我現在告訴你們。
24 創造宇宙和其中萬物的上帝，既是天地的主，就不住人手所造的殿。
26 祂從一本造出萬族的人，(本有古卷作血脈) ，住在全地上，並且豫定準他們的年限，和所住的疆界。
27 要叫他們尋求上帝，或者可以揣摩而得，其實祂離我們各人不遠。
28 我們生活，動作，存留，都在乎祂，就如你們作詩的，有人說，我也是祂所生的。
29 我們既是上帝神所生的，就不當以為上帝的神性像人用手藝，心思，所雕的
金，銀，石。
30 世人蒙昧無知的時後，上帝並不監察，如今卻吩咐各處的人都要悔改。
31 因為祂已經定了日子，要藉著祂所設立的人，按公義審判天下。並且叫從死裏復活，給萬人作可信的憑據。
- 保羅看見偶像心中煩躁。Paul was disturbed because of idol-worship in
- 人 / 社會都有宗教性。Paul observed that men (societies) are deeply
religious.
- 人所敬拜的，他們並不認識。People worship what they don’t know.
- 可是上帝是可知的。他們所不認識的，保羅現在告訴他們。But God is knowable:
What they don’t know,
Paul now declares him to them.
- 上帝是宇宙的創造者。God is creator of universe.
- 因此上帝有權統治宇宙。God is, therefore, rightfully the Lord of the
universe.
- 上帝是自足自存的：祂不需要我們，我們的敬拜、殿宇。God’s aseity (self-
existence): he does not need us, our worship,
our temples.
- 其實，我們一切所是，所有的（生命、氣息）都是祂所賜的。In fact God supplies
ALL that we are/have: life, breath, very being.
- 上帝從一個祖宗創造人類。God created all cultures/peoples from one
ancestor.
- 我們的歷史（年限）與地理（疆界）= 我們的文化 = 上帝所預先定準的。Our
history and geography (= culture) =
pre-appointed by God.
- 這個預定的目的﹕我們尋求上帝，而尋見祂。Purpose of this pre-appointment: that we seek
God, and find him.
- 上帝要我們棄絕偶像敬拜，悔改，歸向祂！Forsake idol worship, repent, and turn to
God!
基本信念，進路 BASIC CONVICTIONS AND APPROACHES
每一個人都按照自己的世界觀思想。基督徒的世界觀來自《聖經》。《聖經》宣稱是上帝所默示的，本身就是最高及絕對的真理。低於《聖經》真理的權威，沒有資格審核它。《聖經》宣告全權之上帝，祂創造了宇宙，並啟示了自己。護教為《聖經》的世界觀提出足夠的支持理由。護教也向非信徒的自主發出挑戰，幫助他對自己的世界觀有更高度的自覺。護教者給非信徒看見，除非他接受《聖經》的世界觀，不然他不可能獲得知識和建立道德的標準。
All people think according to a worldview. The Christian’s worldview comes from the
Bible, which declares itself to be God’s revealed truth inspired by God. The Bible has the highest authority for
mankind; no other lower authority is qualified to evaluate and judge the
Bible. The Bible declares
that God is absolutely sovereign, He created the universe, and has revealed
himself. Apologetics vindicates and justifies
the Bible’s worldview with adequate reasons and evidences. Apologetics confronts the unbeliever’s autonomy, and challenges him to be
self-conscious about his worldview.
Apologetics shows the unbeliever that unless he adopts the Bible’s
worldview, knowledge and morality will not be intelligible.
造物主是主 CREATOR, LORD
《聖經》宣稱神創造天地，天地所有的都是祂造的。有一部分預設派認為，神也創造了世上的秩律和人的思念 (如邏輯的定律)。註﹕范泰爾不接受這觀點。荷蘭神學家(兼首相) 凱伯 (Abraham
Kuyper) 曾說﹕世界裏沒有一塊地土，耶穌不宣稱﹕這是我的。
Argument: The Bible declares that God created
the heavens and the earth; the entire universe was created by God. Some presuppositionalists (e.g. Herman Douyeweerd) believe that God has
also created the laws within the structure of the universe, and man’s thoughts
(e.g. the laws of logic, such as the law of non-contradiction). Note: Van Til does
not agree that God created logic. The Dutch theologian (and one-time Prime
Minister around 1900) Abraham Kuyper said, that there is not any territory in
this world, of which Christ does not say: “It is mine.”
世界觀 WORLDVIEW
每一個人都有自己的哲學、世界觀、預設。哲學主要分為形而上學 (metaphysics)、知識論(epistemology)、倫理學(ethics) 三大範圍 （及其他範圍如歷史哲學 (philosophy of history)、美學 (aesthetics)、政治哲學(political philosophy)、科學哲學與社會學 (the philosophy and sociology of science)等）。
Every person has his own philosophy (worldview,
presupposition). There are three major areas of inquiry in
philosophy: metaphysics (the study of being), epistemology (why/how we know
what we know), and ethics (the study of right).
(There are other areas of inquiry, such as the philosophy of history,
aesthetics (the study of beauty), political philosophy, the philosophy and
sociology of science, etc.)
1. 形而上學
Metaphysics :
宇宙是甚麼（宇宙觀）What is the universe? (world view)
基督徒﹕創造論、一神論。
For the Christian: creation, theism (one God).
非信徒﹕(可能) 進化論、唯物論、無神論或不可知論、印度教與佛教宇宙觀等。
For the non-Christian: (possibly) evolutionism,
materialism (only matter exists), atheism (no God), or agnosticism (it is not
possible to know whether God exists), or the worldviews of Hinduism or
Buddhism.
2. 知識論 Epistemology:
我所知的為何知 。How (why) do I know what I know?
徹底的基督教知識論﹕神的啟示﹕普遍啟示 + 《聖經》。
A consistently Christian epistemology: God has
revealed himself. General revelation +
the Bible (special revelation).
理性主義﹕人的理性決定甚麼是真理 。
The epistemology of rationalism: man’s reason decides what is truth.
世俗科學主義/實驗主義﹕真理乃五官能察驗的東西 (知道事物的外表，而不能知道事物的本質) 。
The epistemology of secular science (scientism)
or empiricism: truth is what can be discerned through sense perception
(scientific experimentation). Empiricism
concedes that: what we know, is only the outward appearance of things, not the
essence of things.
3. 倫理學 Ethics﹕
是非的標則